The Knowledge Crisis of Nursing
a warping between classical phenomenology, ideological methodology and reflexive practice
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15845/praxeologi.v6.4198Keywords:
Classic phenomenology, Knowledge Crisis, Ideological methodology, Praxeology, Nursing theory, Kirkevold, MartinsenAbstract
In Norway and Denmark, the public healthcare is comprehensive, and nurses constitute a large and important part of these healthcare systems. To handle the increasing complex tasks as a nurse requires a broad range of knowledge. In resemblance to the medical profession, who aim to fight disease and maintain health, nursing is at the same time a practical and a theoretical discipline. The aim for nursing is to offer care for people who cannot care for themselves. An interpretation of human science using health- or natural science methods dominates the academic development of knowledge in nursing. In this article, we engage in a theoretical examination of knowledge within the context of nursing academia in Denmark and Norway, drawing comparisons between two prominent positions. The theoretical framework is built up from the tradition of praxeology and critical theory and used as the pervasive analytical lens. As a model to the interpretation of the two positions, we use argument analysis. The results indicate that the dominating clinical nursing science in Denmark and Norway has been a success when it comes to capacity building at hospitals within an academic research tradition similar to the tradition of the medical profession. However, this research primarily contributes with techniques and models, as it focuses on application oriented research and is eager to produce suggestions in and for practice. This is important research, but insufficient when it comes to producing theories on and about nursing practice as a scientific discipline. We argue that this lopsided academic development supports a crisis in knowledge, because it fails to provide nursing with a proper theoretical scientific base. This is needed if nursing should develop as a subject in the scientific university logic and is essential to enable professional reflexivity in order to meet the demands of contemporary nursing care.
References
Aiken L.H., Sloane D., Griffiths P., Rafferty A.M., Bruyneel L., McHugh M., Maier C.B., Moreno-Casbas T., Ball J.E., Ausserhofer D. & Sermeus W. (2017). Nursing skill mix in European hospitals: cross-sectional study of the association with mortality, patient ratings, and quality of care. BMJ quality & safety, 26(7), 559–568. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjqs-2016-005567
Akram, A.S., Mohamad, A. & Akram, S. (2018). The role of clinical instructor in bridging the gap between theory and practise in nursing education. Internation Journal Of Caring Sciences, 11(2), 876-882.
Alvsåker, Y.B. (2023). Velferdsteknologi i norske hjemmetjenester: en praxeologisk studie om statlige visjoner i møte med markedskrefter og kommunale realiteter. [PhD thesis]. University of Bergen.
Aristotle (2019). Nicomachean Ethics. Third edition. Hackett Publishing Company Inc.
Bender, M. (2017). Models versus theories as a primary carrier of nursing knowledge: A philosophical argument. Nursing Philosophy, 19(1). www.doi.org/10.1111/nup.12198
Bourdieu, P. (1973). The three forms of theoretical knowledge. Social Science Information, 12(1), 73-80.
Bourdieu, P. (1977). Outline of a theory of practice. Cambridge Studies in Social Anthropology.
Bourdieu, P. (1990). The logic of Practice. Polity Press.
Bourdieu, P. (2011). Der Tote packt den Lebenden. Neuauflage der Schriften zu Politik & Kultur 2. VSA Verlag.
Bourdieu P., Chamboredon J.-C. & Passeron J.-C. (1991). The Craft of Sociology – Epistemological Preliminaries. De Gruyter.
Broady D. (2000). Introduktion. I P. Bourdieu, Konstens regler. Det litterära fältets uppkomst och struktur. Brutus Östlings bokförlag.
Callewaert S. (1998). Bourdieustudier 2: Det religiøse felts genese og struktur ifølge Pierre Bourdieu, s. 11-84. Institut for Filosofi, Pædagogik og Retorik, Københavns universitet.
Clinton, M. (2023). On Bender's orientation to models: Towards a philosophical debate on covering laws, theory, emergence and mechanisms in nursing science. Nursing Philosophy. www.doi.org/10.1111/nup.12439
Durkheim, É. (2014). Opdragelse, uddannelser og sociologi. Forlaget Mindspace.
Frederiksen, J. (2016). Tværprofessionelle velfærdsprofessioner: Tværsamarbejde som en social praktik for den neoliberale velfærdsstats professioner [PhD thesis]. Roskilde University.
Frederiksen, J. (2019). The Jigsaw Puzzle of Governance by Soft Terms in Healthcare: Capturing the Neoliberal Impact of Health Policy on Nurses’ Work. Praktiske Grunde. Nordisk tidsskrift for kultur- og samfundsvidenskab (1-2), 7-24.
Greenway, K., Butt, G. & Walthall, H. (2019). What is a theory-practice gap? An exploration of the concept. Nurse Education in Practice 34, 1-6. www.doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2018.10.005
Habermas, J. (1990). On the Logic of the Social Sciences. MIT Press.
Kalisch, B.J. & Xie, B. (2014). Errors of Omission: Missed Nursing Care. Western Journal of Nursing Research 36(7). https://doi.org/10.1177/0193945914531859
Kirkevold, M. (1998). Sykeplejeteorier – en analyse og evaluering. Gyldendal Akademisk.
Kirkevold, M. (2021). Sygeplejeteoriens evige aktualitet. I B. Martinsen, P., Dreyer & A.L. Norlyck (Eds.), Sygeplejens superhelte. Sygeplejeteoretikere der styrker klinisk praksis, chap. 1, pp. 13-29. Munksgaard.
Martinsen, K. (1993). Fra Marx til Løgstrup. Om etik og sanselighed i sygeplejen. Tano forlag.
Martinsen, K. (2021). Min rejse med Løgstrup – i filosofi og sygepleje, I B. Martinsen, P., Dreyer & A.L. Norlyck (Eds.), Sygeplejens superhelte. Sygeplejeteoretikere der styrker klinisk praksis. Chap. 2, pp. 31-59. Munksgaard.
Michaelsen, J.J., Ramhøj, P., Larsen, K., Christensen, J.M. & Hansen, H.P. (2023). De ’Bindegale Sygeplejersker’ – en tværfaglig græsrodsbevægelse. Sygeplejersken, Fag og Forskning. Dansk sygepleaad. De 'Bindegale Sygeplejersker' - en tværfaglig græsrodsbevægelse | dsr.dk
Nygård, A.K. (2022). Kunnnskapsproduksjon i sykepleie: En praxeologisk analyse av masteroppgaver i sykepleievitenskap ved Universitetet i Bergen fra perioden 2011-2021 [master’s thesis]. University of Bergen.
Petersen, K.A. (1993). Den praktiske erkendelse: forholdet mellem teori og praksis i sygepleje og Sygeplejerskeuddannelsen. Conference Proceedings, special issue of Skrift-serie nr. 4, The Danish University College at Aarhus University.
Petersen, K.A. (1999). Sygeplejevidenskab - myte eller virkelighed? Om genese og struktur af feltet af akademiske uddannelser og forskning i sygepleje i Danmark. [PhD thesis]. Aarhus University.
Petersen, K.A. (2021). Opkomst og afvikling af faget sykepleievitenskap ved Universitet i Bergen (1979-2019). Praxeology – A critical reflexive view on social practices. https://doi.org/10.15845/praxeologi.v3i0.3205
Petersen, K.A. (2023). Når fænomenologien møder praxeologien. I H. Alvsvåg & I. Hunskår (Eds.) Fra ‘Nødvendige omveier’ til en dag med ‘Langsomme pulsslag’. Rapport 2023/10, pp. 37-49. VID vitenskaplige høgskole.
Petersen, K. A. & Callewaert, S. (2014). Praxeologisk sygeplejevidenskab: Hvad er det? En diskussion med det subjektivistiske og det objektivistiske alternativ. Forlaget Hexis.
Petersen K.A, Høyen, M., Ilkjær, I. & Langbehn, F. (2023). Dansk sygepleje og højere uddannelse: et studie om danske sygeplejerskers uddannelsesvej fra titlen sygeplejerske/ professionsbachelor til forskeruddannelse/ph.d.. Praxeology – A critical reflexive view on social practices. https://doi.org/10.15845/praxeologi.v5.4003
Ryder, M., Kitson, A.L., Slotnes O’Brien, T. & Timmins, F. (2022). Advancing nursing Practice through fundamental care delivery. Journal of nursing management. 30, 601–3. www.doi.org/10.1111/jonm.13402
Salifu, D.A., Gross, J., Salifu, M.A. & Ninnoni, J.P. (2018). Experiences and Perceptions of The theory-practice gap in nursing in a ressource-constrained setting: A qualitative description. Nursing Open 19, 6(1), 72-83. www.doi.org/10.1002/nop2.188
Sortvik, W. (2011). Sjukepleieran som akademisk aktør. Hva er sjukepleie vitenskap? [master’s thesis]. University of Bergen.
Sortvik, W., Boge, J., Callewaert, S. & Petersen, K.A. (2016). Korleis sjukepleievitskap materialiserer seg i lys av historisk oppkomst – kunnskapsgenerering i spenningsfeltet mellom klinikk og akademia. Nordisk Tidsskrift for helseforskning 12(1), 77.
Toulmin, S., Rieke, R.D. & Janik, A. (1979). An Introduction to Reasoning. Macmillan.
University of Oslo (2023). Department of Public Health Science. www.med.uio.no/helsam/personer/vit/maritk/index.html
Vesterdal, A. & Bagh J. (2002). Konstruktiv forskning skal fremmes. Sygeplejersken (16), 26-29.
Williamson, L., Burog, W. & Taylor R.M. (2022). A scoping review of strategies used to
recruit and retain nurses in the health care workforce. Journal of Nursing Management, 30(7), 2845–2853. www.doi.org. 10.1111/jonm.13786.
WHO (2020). State of the world’s nursing 2020: investing in education, jobs and
leadership. World Health Organization.
Wulff, H.R. (1981). Rational Diagnosis and Treatment: An Introduction to Clinical Decision Making. Blackwell.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Jesper Frederiksen, Kim Jørgensen, Karin Anna Petersen
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
